U.S. immigration ledger · FY1997–FY2026

Six presidencies.
One system still breaking.

Thirty years of removals, emergency rules, rising court costs and campaign promises — without a comprehensive immigration settlement.

Quick take

Enforcement changed shape, not direction. Obama recorded the most formal removals in this series; Biden relied heavily on Title 42 expulsions; Trump’s second-term count remains disputed. Meanwhile, active pending court cases rose from 186,140 in 2008 to 1.26 million in 2020; on EOIR’s separate inclusive series, pending cases grew from 826,505 in 2016 to 3.92 million in 2024 — even as court funding more than quintupled from its 2001 level.

01 / REMOVALS

The enforcement line never went flat.

Formal removals are DHS repatriations carrying legal consequences. They are not the same as older “returns,” Title 42 expulsions, or voluntary departures.

3.06MObama formal removals, FY2009–16 — highest term total shown
432,330FY2013 formal removals — record single year
~2.75MTitle 42 expulsions under Biden, separate from removals
290–340KTrump 2nd-term ICE removals, contested partial range

Formal removals by fiscal year

Tap or hover a bar for the exact figure

DHS YEARBOOK TABLE 39
FY2024 uses ICE ERO

Peak: FY2013 · 432,330 formal removals

Series break: FY1997–2023 are DHS-wide formal removals from Table 39. FY2024 is ICE ERO only (271,484), because a DHS-wide FY2024 Yearbook total was not found. Trump’s second-term estimates are excluded from the annual chart because sources and definitions conflict.

Source: DHS Office of Homeland Security Statistics, Yearbook Table 39; FY2024: ICE FY2024 Annual Report.

Clinton II
661K
Bush
2.01M
Obama
3.06M
Trump I
1.20M
Biden
~644K*
Trump II
~315K†
DHS formal removalsHighest term* Mixed DHS/ICE series† Midpoint of contested 290–340K ICE range; partial term
02 / PRESIDENTIAL TERMS

Policy changed. The pressure accumulated.

Each card pairs the enforcement total with the defining fights and the court system inherited at the end of the term. Backlog series and definitions vary; each figure is labeled.

Clinton II

FY1997–2000
660,820formal removals
  • IIRIRA and AEDPA expanded deportable offenses, mandatory detention and expedited removal.
  • Returns still dominated: roughly 1.44M–1.68M each year.
  • Elián González and 1996 welfare restrictions defined the public fight.
211,880 → 159,858court receipts / yr
194,305 → 164,051completions / yr
Gapactive backlog

George W. Bush

FY2001–08
2.01Mformal removals
  • After 9/11, DHS replaced INS; ICE, CBP and USCIS began operations in 2003.
  • Secure Fence Act, Operation Streamline and expanded 287(g) partnerships.
  • Comprehensive reform failed in 2006–07; workplace raids expanded.
186,140end backlog, active
$238.3MEOIR FY2008
$2.381BERO/DRO FY2008

Barack Obama

FY2009–16
3.06Mformal removals · series high
  • FY2013 set the single-year removal record: 432,330.
  • DACA began in 2012; DAPA was blocked and never implemented.
  • SB1070 litigation, the 2014 child-migrant surge and the “deporter in chief” label.
521,672end backlog, active
$422.3MEOIR FY2016
143,478FY2016 completions

Donald Trump I

FY2017–20
1.20Mformal removals
  • Travel ban, family separation, border emergency and Remain in Mexico.
  • Title 42 began in March 2020; FY2020 recorded 206,790 expulsions.
  • Administrative-closure changes re-docketed roughly 330,000 cases, affecting backlog counts.
1.261Mend backlog, active
$673MEOIR FY2020
$4.429BERO FY2020

Joe Biden

FY2021–24
~644Kmixed DHS / ICE formal series
  • About 2.75M Title 42 expulsions — a distinct legal category — dominated the early term.
  • FY2024 ICE removals reached 271,484, the highest ICE figure since 2014.
  • Record encounters, parole programs and the failed 2024 Senate border deal.
3.559Mend backlog, CRS pull
$840MEOIR FY2024
1.784MFY2024 receipts

Donald Trump II

2025–26 · partial
290–340KICE range · contested
  • DHS’s broader 605K–622K public claims include voluntary or self-departures.
  • Laken Riley Act, Alien Enemies Act removals, expanded detention and interior raids.
  • A July 2025 law added roughly $75B for ICE over four years.
3.470MFY2026 Q3 backlog, inclusive
798,014FY2025 completions
$840MEOIR FY2025 CR

Policy sources: Pew’s immigration law timeline, Migration Policy Institute’s Title 42 postmortem, and cited agency records in the source ledger below.

03 / IMMIGRATION COURTS

The backlog became the system.

Two EOIR pending-case series exist: “active” excludes administratively closed cases; the current “inclusive” series counts active and inactive. They cannot be treated as one seamless measure.

Pending cases · EOIR inclusive series

Active + inactive pending cases, FY2016 onward

ONE CONSISTENT SERIES
SELECTED ENDPOINTS

The million-case threshold was crossed in FY2019 — not during the Obama administration.

1.78M in.

EOIR received 1,783,909 new cases in FY2024 and completed 704,949 — intake ran about 2.5 times completions. In FY2025, the balance reversed: 562,372 receipts versus a record 798,014 completions, helping drive the first sustained backlog decline in more than a decade.

Sources: EOIR historical new cases and completions; EOIR current pending-case series; CRS FY2024 court data.

04 / PUBLIC & POLITICAL MONEY

More money bought more capacity — not resolution.

EOIR funds the court system. ICE ERO funds detention and removal operations. Campaign-ad totals use differing media scopes across cycles and should be read as direction, not an inflation-adjusted series.

Immigration courts

EOIR enacted budget, selected fiscal years

FY2001
$159M
FY2008
$238.3M
FY2016
$422.3M
FY2020
$673M
FY2023
$860M
FY2024–25
$840M

Detention & removal

ICE ERO/DRO enacted budget, selected fiscal years

FY2007
$1.984B
FY2008
$2.381B
FY2016
$3.218B
FY2020
$4.429B
FY2024
~$5.08B*
FY2025
~$5.57B*

* Derived from budget exhibits or continuing-resolution levels. Separate July 2025 reconciliation funding added $75B to ICE over four years.

Budget sources: CRS on immigration courts and backlog, CRS FY2024 CJS appropriations, DHS FY2023 justification, and CRS FY2025 DHS appropriations.

The campaign-ad arms race

Reported presidential ad spending by election cycle. Scope varies: TV/radio, TV only, general election only, or all media. These figures are not directly comparable.

2000
~$200M · TV + radio
2004
>$600M · TV + radio
2008
~$335M · TV, full cycle
2012
~$655M · comparable TV series
2016
~$845M · comparable TV series
2020
>$1.5B · broadcast TV, general election
2024
$3.2B · all media, full cycle
No clean dollar figure.

Immigration-specific ad spending could not be isolated for any cycle. Wesleyan measured shares of ad airings instead: immigration appeared in roughly 54% of Trump TV ad airings in Aug–Sept 2020, falling to about 16% in late October; in August 2024 it appeared in 39%–100% of pro-Trump sponsor airings and 50.9% of Harris airings. Those are shares of airings, not dollars.

Ad sources: Wesleyan/Kantar comparable series, Wesleyan 2020 spending, AdImpact 2024 total, Wesleyan 2024 issue focus.

05 / READ THE FINE PRINT

Definitions can move millions.

The central numbers are real. The categories around them are not interchangeable.

  1. Removal ≠ return ≠ expulsion. A formal removal carries legal consequences; historical returns and pandemic-era Title 42 expulsions are counted separately.
  2. Biden’s ~644K total mixes series. DHS-wide Table 39 ends at FY2023; FY2024 uses ICE ERO’s 271,484 removals. The ICE-only four-year total is 545,252.
  3. Trump II is contested. Independent ICE-removal estimates cluster around 290K–340K for the partial period; DHS’s 605K–622K claims include voluntary/self-departures.
  4. Court backlog series differ. Active pending excludes administratively closed cases. The current inclusive series includes inactive cases. Revisions can change historical endpoints.
  5. No official cost per case exists. A rough EOIR budget ÷ completions proxy is about $2,034 in FY2019 and $1,192 in FY2024, but it overstates marginal case cost because EOIR also funds appeals, IT, headquarters and legal-orientation work.
  6. Ad totals are not apples-to-apples. The media covered and campaign windows change across cycles. Immigration-specific dollars were not found; issue mentions are shares of airings.

Source ledger